The Law of Subsidies Under the GATT/WTO System

Author: Marc Benitah
Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.
ISBN: 904119827X
Category: Law
Page: 424
View: 1459

Continue Reading →

This work on the law of subsidies has been long-awaited by many actors in international trade. With its introduction of the concept of 'attenuation' of entitlement, Marc Benitah's utterly new analysis alters our understanding of the international economic law of subsidies - and its future invocation and jurisprudence - forever. The issue of subsidies is arguably the predominant theme, at this moment, in international economic law, and a consistent approach to the legal treatment of subsidies is urgently needed. In Professor Benitah's view, the answer lies in the recognition that entitlements granted to a party seeking to defend itself against the `adverse effects' of subsidies must be `attenuated' in order to avoid undesirable economic and social consequences. In the various techniques of attenuation - thoroughly described and analyzed in this book - may be found the unifying thread on which a logical, coherent law of subsidies may be strung. Why techniques of attenuation are intimately linked to the birth of past and future legal disputes relating to subsidies Why significant techniques of attenuation (e.g. taking into account the positive impact of a subsidy on consumers) have not arisen in the GATT/WTO context Why much recent theoretical debate on the concept of 'distortion' has not led to a breakthrough in the law of subsidies Why attenuations favouring developing countries are surprisingly legally vulnerable in practice Why deliberate recourse to techniques of attenuation necessitates their continuing clarification through a case law process. By referring to the legal materials of both the GATT 1947 and the WTO systems at each point in his demonstration, Professor Benitah lays a substantial groundwork for determining innovative WTO norms.

Die Vereinbarkeit von Strompreisbindungen zugunsten erneuerbarer Energien mit WTO-Recht

eine Untersuchung des Preismodells für regenerative Elektrizität anhand des WTO-Subventionsübereinkommens und GATT
Author: Ivan Zlatanov
Publisher: Peter Lang
ISBN: 9783631586273
Category: Business & Economics
Page: 184
View: 4436

Continue Reading →

Die Arbeit untersucht, ob das System der staatlichen Mindestpreisfestsetzung, verbunden mit einem Abnahmezwang fur die privaten Netzbetreiber und Stromversorgungsunternehmen zugunsten der Erzeuger erneuerbarer Energien, mit WTO/GATT-Recht ubereinstimmt, wobei der Schwerpunkt auf der Prufung der Subventionsvorschriften liegt. Da sich die gesetzlichen Preisstutzungssysteme im Einzelnen voneinander unterscheiden, wird hier nur die Kernstruktur des Preismodells, das allen Regelungsinstrumenten in den einzelnen Staaten zugrunde liegt und gemeinsam ist, auf Vereinbarkeit mit WTO/GATT-Recht uberpruft."

Wto-Recht und Entwicklungsländer

Special and Differential Treatment for Developing Countries Im Multidimensionalen Wandel des Wirtschaftsvölkerrechts
Author: Henning Jessen
Publisher: BWV Verlag
ISBN: 3830521057
Category: Doha Development Agenda
Page: 871
View: 6893

Continue Reading →

Hauptbeschreibung Die Mitglieder der Welthandelsorganisation (WTO) verfolgen seit der IV. Ministerkonferenz von Doha das Ziel, die Bedürfnisse wirtschaftlich schwächerer und am schwächsten entwickelter Staaten in das Zentrum einer ""Entwicklungsrunde"" zu stellen (""Doha Development Agenda""). Neben den Detailfragen des liberalisierten globalen Marktzugangs ist die zukünftige Behandlung dieser großen Mehrheit der WTO-Mitglieder eines der ""Schicksalsthemen"" für die weitere strategische und institutionelle Ausrichtung der WTO. Vor dem Hintergrund interdisziplinärer Erkenntnisse aus.

Fisheries Subsidies under International Law

Author: Chen-Ju Chen
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
ISBN: 9783642156939
Category: Law
Page: 254
View: 2389

Continue Reading →

Subsidies to fisheries have been in existence for centuries. However, these remained outside the spotlight of the international community until the turn of this century when the negative effects that fisheries subsidies have on international trade, the environment and sustainable development became increasingly clear. As a result the Doha Round Negotiations set the parameters for an effective fisheries subsidies regime. WTO Members thus embarked in intensive negotiations with the collaboration of various international organizations. These negotiations culminated with publication of the legal text of the Chairman of the Negotiating Group on Rules in 2007 which reflects to a large extent the mandates of the Ministerial Conferences and reconciles the diverse interests of the negotiators. The EU as a major WTO Member and with its own Common Fisheries Policy which has been in effect for a number of years can serve as the basis for comparison and improvement of the proposed regulations.


World Economic Order, World Trade Law
Author: Peter-Tobias Stoll,Frank Schorkopf
Publisher: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers
ISBN: 900414496X
Category: Law
Page: 291
View: 1746

Continue Reading →

This book describes the institutional system the basic principles and the vast variety of rules of the World Trade Organization. It aims at clarifying the structure and the general concepts, in order to enable the reader to get a better understanding of the issues at stake in many of the discussions and controversies on world trade.


Trade Remedies
Author: Rüdiger Wolfrum,Peter-Tobias Stoll,Michael Köbele
Publisher: BRILL
ISBN: 9004145656
Category: Political Science
Page: 980
View: 1815

Continue Reading →

In the decade since the establishment of the WTO, the great majority of disputes between member states resolved and decided through the dispute settlement system of the WTO arose in the field of trade remedies law, a fact which clearly shows the high demand by the trade community for the rule of law in this area. Responsive to such needs, the fourth volume encompasses the whole range of trade remedies regulation under the auspices of the WTO in the respective articles of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the related multilateral agreements on trade in goods, i.e., Articles VI, XII, XIX GATT 1994; the Understanding on the Balance-of-Payments; the Agreement on Implementation of Article VI GATT 1994 (Anti-Dumping Agreement); the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Duties; and the Agreement on Safeguards. Leading practitioners and scholars have gathered to provide an invaluable insight and easy access to the law on trade remedies in an article-by-article commentary approach. As such, it will be an essential work not only for trade remedies practitioners but to persons interested in trade remedies be they scholars, academics, international and domestic lawyers, political scientists and economists, or NGO representatives.

trade remedies and non- market economies: economic implications of the first US countervailing duty case on china

Author: Yan Wang
Publisher: World Bank Publications
Page: N.A
View: 9726

Continue Reading →

In 2007, the United States Department of Commerce altered a 23-year old policy of not applying the countervailing duty law to non-market economies, and initiated eight countervailing and antidumping duty investigations on Chinese imports. The change brings heated debate on trade remedy policies and issues of non-market economies. This study focuses on the first countervailing duty case on imported coated free sheet paper from China and analyzes the implications of this test case for United States-China bilateral trade, and industrial policies in transitioning market economies. The paper also provides a brief review of the economics of subsidies, World Trade Organization rules on subsides and countervailing measures, and United States countervailing duty laws applied to non-market economies. While recently acceded countries should review their domestic development policies from the perspective of economic efficiency and comply with the World Trade Organization rules, it is also important to further clarify the issues of non-market economies under the multilateral trading system, and pay keen attention to the rules negotiations in the current World Trade Organization Doha Development Round.

OECD Steel and Shipbuilding Subsidy Negotiations

Text and Legal Analysis
Author: Fabrizio Pagani
Publisher: Cameron May
ISBN: 1905017669
Category: Foreign trade regulation
Page: 477
View: 4238

Continue Reading →

From 2003 through 2005 the OECD hosted talks among major producing countries aimed at reducing subsidies in the steel and shipbuilding industries.

The Regulation of Subsidies Within the General Agreement on Trade in Services of the WTO

Problems and Prospects
Author: Pietro Poretti
Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.
ISBN: 9041131620
Category: Law
Page: 317
View: 702

Continue Reading →

"The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) extends the multilateral trading system to services. Little is said In the GATS about subsidies, beyond stipulating that subsidies are subject to the existing provisions, including the most-favoured-nation and national-treatment principles, and that Members shall enter into negotiations with a view to developing the disciplines necessary to avoid the trade distorting effects of subsidies." "This timely book provides a comprehensive analysis of services subsidies under the GATS. It begins with a description of services and trade in services, and of the salient characteristics that make regulation of services subsidies more complex than those associated with agricultural and industrial goods. It then analyzes the economic arguments underpinning the need for regulation, as well as the need for governments to retain sufficient latitude to implement non-trade-related policy measures. A description of the information available on services subsidies is followed by a classification of services subsidies according to their distortive effects, and by a detailed analysis of those elements that may form a definition of services subsidies for the purpose of a future regulatory framework." "A key section is devoted to the analysis of those existing provisions of the GATS that may exert a certain measure of discipline on services subsidies, and to the question of the desirability and technical feasibility of countervailing measures. Rules on services subsidies contained in regional trade agreements and the need for special and differential treatment for services subsidies by developing countries are also discussed. Finally, and prior to the conclusion, two sectoral studies deal with the question of subsidies aimed at attracting foreign direct investment and subsidies to the audiovisual sector." "This work represents the first extensive and comprehensive analysis of the issue of services subsidies in the context of the GATS, and includes numerous references to relevant European Union State Aid legislation and jurisprudence." --Book Jacket.

The Gatt/Wto Dispute Settlement System

International Law, International Organizations and Dispute Settlement
Author: Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann
Publisher: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers
ISBN: 9789041109330
Category: Political Science
Page: 344
View: 1901

Continue Reading →

The GATT and WTO dispute settlement systems have become the most frequently used international mechanisms for the settlement of trade disputes among governments. The 1994 Agreement Establishing the WTO introduced a historically unprecedented new dispute settlement procedure for conflicts involving trade in goods and services, trade-related investment measures, and intellectual property rights. This procedure provided for the compulsory jurisdiction of the WTO Dispute Settlement Body, WTO Panels, and the WTO Appellate Body. The first 18 months from the time the WTO Agreement came into force on 1 January 1995 witnessed more than 50 invocations of the new dispute settlement procedures by a large number of countries, including many from the developing world. This large response, and the proposals for further extending the scope of WTO law, suggest that the WTO dispute settlement system will continue to be the most frequently applied, worldwide systems for the legal settlement of trade disputes among governments. This book provides students, lawyers and diplomats a thought-provoking and practice-oriented analysis of the GATT/WTO dispute settlement rules, procedures, and problems. The Annexes include a useful collection of relevant texts and tables of past GATT and WTO case law.

From Gatt to the WTO:The Multilateral Trading System

Author: World Trade Organization,Edward McWhinney,World Trade Organization. Secretariat,WTO Secretariat
Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.
ISBN: 9041112537
Category: Law
Page: 183
View: 7567

Continue Reading →

Om det nuværende og fremtidige verdenshandelsystem

The Regulation of Agricultural Subsidies in the World Trade Organization Framework. A Developing Country Perspective

Author: Farai Chigavazira
ISBN: 3960675593
Category: Law
Page: 209
View: 2154

Continue Reading →

The Agreement on Agriculture (AoA) was adopted to eliminate the illegitimate use of trade distorting agricultural subsidies and, thereby, reduce and avoid the negative effects subsidies have on global agricultural trade. However, the AoA has been fashioned in a way that is enabling developed countries to continue high levels of protectionism through subsidization, whilst many developing countries are facing severe and often damaging competition from imports artificially cheapened through subsidies. The regulation of subsidies by the World Trade Organisation (WTO) has been a highly sensitive issue. This is mainly due to the fear of compromising on food security, especially by developed countries. Developing countries have suffered negatively from the subsidy programmes of developed countries, which continue to subsidize their agricultural sector. This position of developing countries in the global trade system, which has been described as weak, has drawn criticism of the WTO, namely that it does not protect the interests of the weak developing nations, but rather strengthens the interests of the strong developed nations. The green box provisions which are specifically designed to regulate payments that are considered trade neutral or minimally trade distorting have grossly been manipulated by developed countries at the mercy of the AoA. Developed countries continue to provide trade distorting subsidies under the guise of green box support. This is defeating the aims and objectives of the AoA. The study examines the regulation of WTO agricultural subsidies from the developing countries’ perspective. It looks at the problems WTO member states face with trade distorting subsidies, but focuses more on the impact these have on developing states. It scrutinizes the AoA’s provisions regulating subsidies by adopting a perspective to identify any loopholes or shortcomings which undermine the interests and aspirations of developing countries. This is against the background that some of the provisions of the AoA are lenient towards the needs of developed countries at the expense of developing countries.

Tied Aid and Development Aid Procurement in the Framework of EU and WTO Law

The Imperative for Change
Author: Annamaria La Chimia
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing
ISBN: 1782251618
Category: Law
Page: 488
View: 2440

Continue Reading →

This book is the first legal treatment of tied aid and examines in detail the compatibility of tied aid with EU and WTO law. The workings of the aid projects and aid procurement systems of donor countries granting bilateral aid are fully examined through case studies from the UK, Italy, the EU and the US. Tied aid refers to aid granted to developing countries on condition that goods and services for the aid-financed projects are purchased from the donor country only. The recipient country, in order to receive the grant or the loan, has no other choice but to fulfil the condition imposed by the donor. Economists have shown that tying aid undermines the effectiveness of aid. It leads to higher costs paid for the goods and services purchased and the distortion of the nature of the aid. Further, tying frustrates the potential of aid to foster trade between developing countries - in many of these countries public bodies and, in particular, aid-financed projects are major potential outlets for trade between neighbouring states. The importance of tied aid has been pointed out in economic literature but there is surprisingly little written on the legal aspects of tied aid practices and this book seeks to fill this major gap in the literature. The book is of interest to academics in the field of EU and WTO law, NGOs and practitioners working both in the field of public procurement and development policies.